Les MouettesvsHotel Villa Marie Saint Barth
Both hotels are endorsed by experts. On balance, Villa Marie Saint-Barth ranks marginally higher than Les Mouettes. Villa Marie Saint-Barth ranks #19 in St. Barth's with accolades from 3 publications like Mr & Mrs Smith, The Telegraph and Jetsetter.
Les Mouettes
 Fodor's
 BlackBook
 Travel + Leisure
 Lonely Planet
Quartier Lorient, St. Jean 97133, St Barthelemy
From $0/night
- Kitchenette
 - Air Conditioning
 - Beach
 
 "This guesthouse offers clean, simply furnished, and economical bungalows that open directly onto the beach." Full review
 "Seven cozy cottages anchored right on Lorient Beach create a Gilligan's Island feel. Double beds and full kitchen make these abodes inviting for both a party posse or a family." 
 "Situated directly on Lorient Beach, this relatively affordable hotel makes up for its modest design with a prime location on the water." Full review
 "For budget-conscious beach lovers, it's hard to imagine a more appealing spot." Full review
Hotel Villa Marie Saint Barth
 Jetsetter
 Mr & Mrs Smith
 The Telegraph
Colombier 97133, St. Barthelemy
From $964/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Bar/Lounge
 - Hot Tub
 - Room Service
 - Free Breakfast
 - Laundry Service
 
 "A celebrity-worthy stay in your own luxurious bungalow on the Caribbean's most exclusive island." Full review
 "High on a hill on the Colombier coast, luxury Hotel Villa Marie combines our favourite bits of the Côte d’Azur and Caribbean." Full review
 i 
The hotel has all you could ask for in the West Indies; swim in the outdoor pool surrounded by exotic gardens, fall madly in love with beautiful bay views from a bar sloshed with rum and peddling rich cigars, and have tête-à-têtes with the hotel’s pair of chatty pet parrots – all the Smith essentials…
9.0
 "The debut property of Maison & Hotels Sibuet outside mainland France, Villa Marie, sits in the hills above the Bay of Flamands." Full review