La CasevsLe Tamarin
Both restaurants are rated very highly by professional travelers. Overall, La Case de l'Isle ranks marginally better than Le Tamarin. La Case de l'Isle comes in at #5 in St. Barth's with positive reviews from 4 reviews including Fodor's, Frommer's and BlackBook.
La Case
Fodor's
BlackBook
Frommer's
Travel + Leisure
Hotel Saint-Barth Isle de France, Anse des Flamands, St Barthelemy
From $0/night
Fodor's "You can't top the view or the service at this waterfront restaurant at the renowned Cheval Blanc St-Barth Isle de France." Full review
BlackBook "Ladies who lunch take note: La Casa is where food meets fashion."
Frommer's "The signature restaurant at the Isle de France resort is, like the hotel, pretty wonderful in every way." Full review
Travel + Leisure "For an elegant lunch, nothing beats the seaside restaurant at the Cheval Blanc hotel, with its white tablecloths, wooden floors, campaign chairs, and rose-colored glasses." Full review
Le Tamarin Frommer's BlackBook Fodor's Travel + Leisure Travel + Leisure Travel + Leisure
Grande Saline St, Grande Saline, St Barthelemy
From $0/night
Frommer's "The perfect place for a lazy afternoon on the beach, this open-air bistro sits amid rocky hills and forests on the road to Plage de Saline, in a thatched gingerbread cottage." Full review
BlackBook "Famed for leisurely lunches that last a bit too long."
Fodor's "A leisurely lunch here en route to Grande Saline beach is a St. Barth must, but this spot is also tops for dinner or an after-beach snack, too. " Full review
i
Don't miss the beautifully presented, enormous profiteroles for dessert.
Travel + Leisure "A 200-year-old tamarind tree marks the entrance of this lovely, atmospheric restaurant, which is a perfect stopover on the way to Salines Beach." Full review
Travel + Leisure "If you're seeking a more casual-feeling restaurant that still maintains the ultra-chic vibe of St. Barts, opt for something different at Le Tamarin."
St. Barts Travel Guide
September 9, 2021
Travel + Leisure "When the sun goes down, Le Tamarin is a sultry place to be. Set in a lush garden, the restaurant gives off tropical vacation vibes. Couples and groups of friends love the romantic yet vibrant energy"
