Oyster Bay Beach Resort vs The Villas at Simpson Bay Beach Resort & Marina

Both properties are rated highly by professional reviewers writing for major publications. Overall, Oyster Bay Beach Resort scores significantly better than The Villas at Simpson Bay Resort & Marina. Oyster Bay Beach Resort comes in at 80 with praise from 4 sources such as Fodor's, Travel + Leisure and Frommer's.

Oyster Bay Beach Resort

Tripexpert score:

7 / 10

Location: Emerald Merit Rd 10, Oyster Pond 97150, St Maarten-St Martin

Price:

From $185 /night

Amenities:

Bar/Lounge
Hot Tub
Free Internet
Laundry Service
Concierge
Laundy Room

show all amenities

Expert reviews:

Frommer's

"At the end of a twisting, scenic road... this retreat was originally designed for vacationers who don't like overly commercialized megaresorts; now it's largely a timeshare." Full review

Fodor's

"Jutting out into Oyster Bay, this happening condo/time-share resort sits on Dawn Beach. The renovated rooms are spacious and neat, with fresh paint and granite bath vanities." Full review

If you can, get a renovated unit.

Travel + Leisure

"This condo resort and timeshare complex sprawls along the tip of a narrow sandy peninsula between the ocean and Oyster Pond marina." Full review

Star Service

"This expansive operation continues to provide families and couples in search of residential comfort a dependable option with more regional than international flavor." Full review

Oyster

Upper-middle-range

"Rooms are modern and come in studio and one- or two-bedroom configurations, and many have kitchens." Full review

The infinity pool is a highlight with its attractive curved design and beautiful views of the ocean.

Book now

The Villas at Simpson Bay Beach Resort & Marina