The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club, Autograph CollectionvsBarefoot Bay Resort and Marina
Both properties are recommended by expert reviewers. On balance, The Vinoy Renaissance St. Petersburg Resort & Golf Club is the choice of most professionals compared to Barefoot Bay Resort and Marina. The Vinoy Renaissance St. Petersburg Resort & Golf Club comes in at #1 in Tampa Bay Area with accolades from 10 sources such as Gayot, Travel + Leisure and Frommer's.
The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club, Autograph Collection
 Frommer's
 DK Eyewitness
 Star Service
 Rough Guide
 Michelin Guide
 Gayot
 Zagat
 Travel + Leisure
 Fodor's
 U.S. News & World Report Show All Reviews 
501 Fifth Ave NE, St. Petersburg, FL 33701
From $199/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Bar/Lounge
 - Hot Tub
 - Room Service
 - Laundry Service
 - Concierge
 
 "The city's finest hotel. Dominating the northern part of downtown, it overlooks Tampa Bay and is within walking distance of the Pier, Central Avenue, and other attractions." Full review
 i 
If you need enough room to sit outside, request a balconied unit in the new Tower Wing.
 "Within walking distance of The Pier and Central Avenue, this Meditteranean-style resort is one of the most upmarket stays in the area." 
 "Opposite a large park and marina, half a mile northeast of the city center, the resort has a colorful history and equally colorful design." Full review
 "If you want to stay over in style, try this pink hotel opened in 1925 as a haven for the rich and famous." 
 "Babe Ruth was among the celebrities who wintered at this opulent Mediterranean Revival 1925 landmark, considered one of St. Pete's architectural jewels." 
 "This is the place to stay if you're seeking the city's most up-market accommodations." 
4.2
 ""Old charm" and "restored beauty" usher guests into a "historic" era of "movie-star" glamour at this "classy", "idyllic" St. Petersburg landmark." 
 "Venerable 1925 bay-front Mediterranean-style hotel, complete with its own 74-slip marina, in a convenient location near shopping and museums." Full review
 "Thoughtful renovations keep its yesteryear glamour and spot on the National Register of Historic Places." Full review
1.0
 "Picturesquely positioned on St. Petersburg, Florida's beautiful waterfront, The Vinoy Renaissance St. Petersburg Resort & Golf Club has elegant and anchored boats in its sights. Travelers..." Full review
Barefoot Bay Resort and Marina
 Frommer's
 Rough Guide
401 East Shore Drive, Clearwater, FL 33767
From $100/night
- Free Internet
 - Laundy Room
 - Pool
 - Free Parking
 - Kitchenette
 - Dry Cleaning
 
 "A family-owned-and-operated motel on the bay, Barefoot Bay offers clean, comfortable apartment-like accommodations at great prices." Full review
 "This small, family-owned hotel, perched on Clearwater Bay, offers a variety of brightly painted rooms with fridge and microwave. $80."