RumFish Beach at TradeWindsvsHollander Hotel
Both properties are rated highly by reviewers writing for major publications. Overall, Hollander Hotel scores slightly higher than Guy Harvey Outpost, a TradeWinds Beach Resort. Hollander Hotel scores 79 with positive reviews from 3 sources like Fodor's, Lonely Planet and Oyster.
RumFish Beach at TradeWinds
 Star Service
 Gayot
 Fodor's
6000 Gulf Blvd, Saint Pete Beach, FL 33706
From $139/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Shuttle Bus
 - Laundry Service
 
 "Located near the convention center, this is Tradewinds Resorts' entry-level offering on the beach, a more-than modest midrange hotel with low rates and friendly service." Full review
 i 
Be sure to request one of the renovated rooms when checking in.
 "One of the few hotels in the area with an on-site kosher kitchen." 
 "The namesake artist's trademark vibrantly painted swordfish, mahimahi, and other sea creatures adorn the walls of this high-rise beachfront hotel that offers good options for both dining and exploring." Full review
Hollander Hotel
 Oyster
 Fodor's
 Lonely Planet
421 4th Avenue North, St. Petersburg, FL 33701
From $116/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Laundry Service
 - Concierge
 - Laundy Room
 
3.0
 "Mixes an eclectic style with Old Florida charm, without a lot of frills." Full review
 "This chicly renovated 1933 hotel and restaurant on the edge of downtown has become a hub for visitors and local alike and offers a less pricey alternative to the Vinoy." Full review
Top choice
 "Stepping assuredly into St Pete's hotel scene the Hollander can do no wrong with its art-deco flavor, 130-ft porch, convivial Tap Room, full-service spa and serious Brew D Licious coffee shop." Full review