Turtle Beach Resort & InnvsThe Mansion House Inn
Both hotels are endorsed by those who travel for a living. On balance, Turtle Beach Resort is preferred by most writers compared to The Mansion House Inn. Turtle Beach Resort comes in at 81 with positive reviews from 4 reviews such as Frommer's, Fodor's and DK Eyewitness.
Turtle Beach Resort & Inn
 Frommer's
 Concierge
 DK Eyewitness
 Fodor's
9049 Midnight Path Road, Siesta Key, FL 34242
From $295/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Hot Tub
 - Free Internet
 - Concierge
 - Laundy Room
 - Pool
 
 "On Siesta Key's south end, this intimate bayside charmer is one of Florida's most romantic retreats." Full review
 "This Siesta Key resort's pet-friendly policy draws animal lovers to its sublimely peaceful 20-suite complex overlooking the bay and the gulf." 
 "An intimate retreat with five cottages, as well as five rooms in a more modern building." 
 "Reminiscent of a quieter time, many of the cottages at this friendly, affordable, family- and pet-friendly resort date to the 1940s, a romantic plus for yesteryear lovers." Full review
The Mansion House Inn
 Frommer's
 Michelin Guide
 DK Eyewitness
 Gayot
 Lonely Planet
105 5th Ave NE, St. Petersburg, FL 33701
From $88/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Free Internet
 - Pool
 - Free Parking
 - Kitchenette
 - Spa
 
 "The comfortable living room in the main house, which has 6 of the 12 units, opens to a sunroom, off which a small screened porch provides mosquito-free lounging." Full review
 i 
Try to book the Pembroke Room, upstairs over the carriage house. 
 "Cozy and casual, these two historic homes and carriage house create a comfortable oasis." 
 "A courtyard separates the two picturesque early 19th-century buildings that house this cosy B&B." 
 "Like many urban B&Bs, there is an emphasis here on antiques and style." 
 "Two turn-of-the-century buildings with 12 rooms shelter a lovely courtyard with a small pool and hot tub on the edge of the Old Northeast."