Synagogue of Saint Mary the WhitevsMuseo de Santa Cruz
Both are recommended by those who travel for a living. On balance, Museo de Santa Cruz ranks significantly higher than Synagogue of Saint Mary the White. Museo de Santa Cruz has a TripExpert Score of 89 with endorsements from 4 reviewers such as Michelin Guide, Lonely Planet and Frommer's.
Synagogue of Saint Mary the White Fodor's
 Fodor's Lonely Planet
 Lonely Planet Michelin Guide
 Michelin Guide
Reyes Catolicos 4, Toledo
From $0/night
 "Founded in 1203, Toledo's second synagogue is nearly two centuries older than the more elaborate Tránsito." 
 "The lesser of Toledo's two Mudéjar synagogues has five naves divided by rows of horseshoe and multifoil arches...you can admire stucco work and gleaming ornate capitals (but not a whole lot more)." Full review
 1 Star
 "The main Jewish temple in Toledo at the end of the 12C, it was given in 1405 to the Knights of Calatrava, after having been transformed into a church." Full review
Museo de Santa Cruz Lonely Planet
 Lonely Planet Michelin Guide
 Michelin Guide Fodor's
 Fodor's Frommer's
 Frommer's
Calle Miguel de Cervantes, 3, Toledo
From $0/night
 "The various art and sculpture exhibits are backed up by interesting explanatory boards that place all the pieces into historical context." Full review
 2 Stars
 "The museum houses a fine collection of paintings and some fifteen canvases by El Greco, giving an insight into the artist's style." Full review
 "In a beautiful Renaissance hospital with a stunning classical-plateresque facade, this museum is open all day without a break (unlike many of Toledo's other sights)." Full review
 "If you want to get close to masterpieces by El Greco, make this museum your first stop." Full review