The Naturalist Beach Resort vs ?

"Right on the beach, tucked into the corner of Big Bay at the bottom of the road between the two bays, with some lovely all-wood rooms upstairs."

"Just above Castara's main beach. The Naturalist has clean and neatly decorated apartments, all equipped with kitchenettes."

"This cheerful, family-run place is at beach level, and its cozy apartments include kitchens, fans and air-con, and are all different; some have water views." Full review