Historic C.O.D. RanchvsSanta Rita Lodge
Both properties are endorsed by experts. On balance, Santa Rita Lodge ranks slightly better than Historic C.O.D. Ranch. Santa Rita Lodge has a TripExpert Score of 69 with praise from 1 reviewers like Frommer's.
Historic C.O.D. Ranch
 Gayot
P.O. Box 241, Oracle, AZ 85623
From $0/night
- Free Internet
 - Restaurant
 - Pool
 - Free Parking
 - Air Conditioning
 
 "A rustic and remote southwest group retreat and special event facility." 
Santa Rita Lodge
 New York Times
 Frommer's
1218 S. Madera Canyon Road, Madera Canyon, AZ 85614
From $0/night
- Free Internet
 - Family Friendly
 - Free Parking
 - Kitchenette
 - Air Conditioning
 - Refrigerator
 
 "At the Santa Rita Lodge in the largely undeveloped canyon, I checked into a creekside casita ($160) and was asked to keep my showers short because of the drought" 
A Birding Adventure in Arizona’s ‘Sky Islands’
June 15, 2021
 "In the shady depths of Madera Canyon, this lodge primarily hosts bird-watchers and hikers...the simply furnished rooms and cabins are large and comfortable, and all have kitchenettes " Full review