Papaya Playa ProjectvsZamas Hotel
Both properties are praised by writers. Overall, Papaya Playa Project ranks significantly higher than Zamas. Papaya Playa Project scores 88 with praise from 5 reviewers like The Telegraph, Jetsetter and Oyster.
Papaya Playa Project
 Afar Magazine
 Jetsetter
 Travel + Leisure
 The Telegraph
 Travel + Leisure
 Michelin Guide
Km 4-5 Carr Tulum-Boca Paila, Tulum 77780
From $355/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Shuttle Bus
 - Concierge
 - Restaurant
 - Pool
 
 "Papaya Playa Project, in keeping with its natural surroundings, is low-key and laid-back." Full review
 "Design Hotel’s breezy collection of beachside thatch-roofed cabanas in the heart of rustic-chic Tulum." Full review
 "There are several villas here that are great for families, each with multiple bedrooms, a pool, and a private walkway to the beach. Like most hotels in Tulum, the beach here is the star attraction." Full review
8.0
 "Stylish, sustainable palapa huts on a seemingly deserted stretch of white-sand Caribbean coastline." Full review
 "In Tulum, Papaya Playa Project is achingly cool with thatched villas, a beach club packed with digital nomads by day and stylish clubbers at night, and a robust calendar of wellness events" 
 "Something of a throwback to the days when Tulum hadn’t yet filled up with luxury boutique hotels, the ultra-bohemian, ultra-sustainable Papaya Playa Project is nothing if not unique" Full review
Zamas Hotel
 Fodor's
 Jetsetter
 Oyster
 Travel + Leisure
Carretera Tulum-Boca Paila, Km 5, Tulum 77780
From $162/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Laundry Service
 - Concierge
 - Restaurant
 - Family Friendly
 
 "On wild Punta Piedra (Rock Point), Zamas has small, rustic cabanas with palapa roofs and ocean views as far as the eye can see; comfortable beds, tile bathrooms, and bright Mexican colors." Full review
 "Beachside pad near Tulum’s Mayan ruins, with palapa-roofed cabanas and a petite, popular restaurant." Full review
 Mid-Range
 "Zamas is a largely unplugged three-pearl hotel with generator-operated power, set on the beach on the northern edge of Tulum's hotel zone." Full review
 "One of Tulum’s most long-standing hotels, Zamas opened 23 years ago with one restaurant and just one room on two acres of space." Full review