23 St. Mary'svsThe Fort
Both properties are rated highly by those who travel for a living. Overall, The Fort Boutique Hostel scores slightly better than 23 St. Mary's. The Fort Boutique Hostel is ranked #32 in York with positive reviews from 2 reviewers like Rough Guide, Lonely Planet.
23 St. Mary's
 Lonely Planet
23 St Mary's, Bootham, York YO30 7BZ
From $77/night
- Free Internet
 - Free Breakfast
 - Laundry Service
 - Free Parking
 - Multilingual
 - Breakfast included
 
 "A smart and stately town house with nine chintzy, country house-style rooms, some with hand-painted furniture for that rustic look, while others are decorated with antiques." Full review
The Fort
 Rough Guide
 Lonely Planet
1 Little Stonegate, York YO1 8AX
From $16/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Laundy Room
 - Restaurant
 - Kitchenette
 - Baggage storage
 
 "An interesting idea – a “boutique hostel” in the city centre, offering rooms and dorms decorated on themes (log cabin, deep sea creatures) at a knock-down price." 
 "This boutique hostel showcases the work of young British designers, creating affordable accommodation with a dash of character and flair." Full review