Melton Guest HousevsSafestay York - Micklegate
Both Bishops Guest Accomodation and Safestay York are endorsed by professional reviewers. Overall, Safestay York scores significantly higher than Bishops Guest Accomodation. Safestay York scores 80 with approval from 3 reviews like Lonely Planet, Rough Guide and The Telegraph.
Melton Guest House
 The Telegraph
135 Holgate Road, York YO24 4DF
From $141/night
- Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Laundry Service
 - Free Parking
 - Dry Cleaning
 - Breakfast buffet
 
8.0
 "Smart, spotless and with no aspirations towards the luxury end of the market, Bishops does what it says on the tin." Full review
Safestay York - Micklegate
 Rough Guide
 Lonely Planet
 The Telegraph
88 - 90 Mickelgate, York YO1 6JX
From $14/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Bar/Lounge
 - Laundry Service
 - Laundy Room
 - Smoking Rooms
 - Multilingual
 
 "In a handsome 1752 building in the centre of the city, with many impressive features." 
Top choice
 "A large and well-equipped boutique hostel that is popular with school groups and stag and hen parties – don't come here looking for peace and quiet!" Full review
8.0
 "For the cost, this bright, buzzing, brilliant, neon-splashed reinvention of the hostel — housed in a historic Georgian building close to the city walls — is a hard-to-beat budget option." Full review