Experts' Choice Award The Poop Deck
What the experts agree on
The Poop Deck's winning formula is fresh-caught seafood with harbor views—experts consistently praise the conch fritters, daily catch, and relaxed vibe from its harborside balcony perch. Over 40 years of local expertise.
Travel + Leisure "The winning formula seems to combine a casual dining atmosphere, harbor-side balcony perch, and fresh seafood handpicked by customers (and more than 40 years in the business). " Full review
Frommer's "Overlooks the small boat marina of the harbor, a lovely view which sets the tone for a fine meal of excellent fresh seafood—always catch of the day, never frozen, prepared how you like it." Full review
Fodor's "Start with the conch fritters, then move on to the fish...the Seafood Lover's Delight is another great choice. The extensive wine list will provide the perfect accompaniment to any dish." Full review
i
Save room for guava duff and a calypso coffee made with secret ingredients.
