Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant

Save
Top 1% of restaurants in Indianapolis
7 / 10

3 expert reviews

“Set inside a stucco Mediterranean-style villa, this Meridian-Kessler area restaurant sticks to mainstream Italian classics, which suits its loyal clientele just fine.”

– Where

Gayot Gayot
13.0
"Arrive early on the weekends for less of a wait, or order a glass of wine and enjoy the feel of Italy while awaiting a table on the vine-covered patio or in one of the intimate dining rooms." Full review
Zagat Zagat
"A South Broad Ripple institution, this romantic Italian kitchen offers up elevated takes on red-sauce classics alongside a lengthy wine menu." Full review