L'EnclumevsThe Masons Arms
Both hotels are praised by reviewers writing for major publications. On balance, L'Enclume scores slightly better than The Masons Arms. L'Enclume scores 86 with praise from 3 sources including Michelin Guide, Travel + Leisure and The Telegraph.
L'Enclume
 Michelin Guide
 Travel + Leisure
 The Telegraph
 Independent
Cavendish St, Cartmel LA11 6PZ
From $0/night
- Free Internet
 - Free Breakfast
 - Restaurant
 - Accessible
 - Bathrobes
 - Flatscreen TV
 
 2 Stars
 "Inventive, modern cooking uses top quality produce to create dishes with a pleasing lightness and a superb balance of flavours. Home-grown and foraged ingredients feature highly." Full review
 "Since the opening of this great value hotel in 2002, chef-owner Simon Rogan’s inventive cooking has quietly grown in acclaim, culminating in a Michelin star for the restaurant in 2005." Full review
9.0
 "Simon Rogan's two-Michelin-starred restaurant plus handful of rooms stay true both to the simple village location and rich surrounding land." Full review
 "This is a wonderfully higgledy-piggledy sort of place, actually a restaurant with a smattering of cottage rooms dotted around the village of Cartmel" 
The Masons Arms
 Lonely Planet
 Fodor's
 The Telegraph
Strawberry Bank, Cartmel LA11 6NW
From $0/night
- Pet Friendly
 - Bar/Lounge
 - Free Internet
 - Room Service
 - Restaurant
 - Free Parking
 
Top choice
 "Three miles east near Bowlands Bridge, the marvellous Mason's Arms is a local secret." Full review
 "With fabulous views over the rolling countryside of the Winster Valley to the east of Windermere, the Masons Arms is a slate-floored traditional old inn serving local ales and good pub food." Full review
8.0
 "Traditional Lakeland pub, in a quiet setting with sensational views and all the right ingredients - cosy snugs, toasty fires, low-beamed ceilings, plus handsome cooking and decent ales." Full review