Top 1% of restaurants in Milwaukee
8 / 10

3 expert reviews

“Famed for its desserts—house-made pies, cookies and cupcakes in particular—as well as hearty breakfast and brunch options, this hip Bay View spot buzzes with an eclectic crowd of locals.”

– Where

Gayot Gayot
"With deer heads mounted on the wall and an antique illustrated map of the neighborhood, as well as retro cookbooks stacked on a shelf, Honeypie oozes vintage-chic." Full review
For lunch and dinner, choose from hearty (grass-fed lamb and beef meatloaf, venison chili) or lighter options, like the salad of locally harvested micro greens with grilled artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers and pickled red onions.
Zagat Zagat
"A “good spot to fill up” say fans of this Bay View American where the “creative” comfort food is “better than mama could do” and the sweet offerings include pie that's “in the name for good reason”." Full review