Experts' Choice Award L'Isola
What the experts agree on
A romantic, Creole-house setting in downtown Gustavia sets the scene for upscale, city-caliber Italian fare—think risotto with langoustines and standout pastas—that's a refined break from local Creole cuisine.
“Risotto, a surprisingly popular dish on this tropical island, comes with langoustines and baby artichokes or mussels, clams, shrimp, and calamari.”
– Concierge
Fodor's "The chic sister of Santa Monica, California's Via Veneto packs in happy guests for classic Italian dishes, dozens of house-made pasta dishes, prime meats, and a huge, well-chosen wine..." Full review
BlackBook "Santa Monica comes to downtown Gustavia. Arugula salad, prosciutto, and taglietelle that's a needed respite from all the Creole kitchens in the neighborhood."
Travel + Leisure "Beloved by both locals and visitors, this upscale Italian favorite wouldn’t feel out of place in a fashionable city like Milan or Paris." Full review
Frommer's "Tucked inside a vintage Creole house in downtown Gustavia, this très elegant, dimly lit spot is a celebratory place to be, as much for the romantic ambience as for consistently excellent food." Full review
